Hymns in Any Key

It Came upon the Midnight Clear

Words: Edmund H. Sears (1810–1876), 1849. Music: CAROL, Richard S. Willis (1819–1900), 1850. C.M.D. (8.6.8.6 D).

All five verses of “It Came upon the Midnight Clear” with chords and Richard Storrs Willis’s tune CAROL, ready to print in any key. It is printed in B♭, as in the 1905 Methodist Hymnal; the melody stays within one octave, from D up to D.

BBEF1.Itcameuponthemidnightclear,That2.StillthroughtheclovenskiestheycomeWith3.YetwiththewoesofsinandstrifeThe4.Andye,beneathlife’scrushingload,Whose5.Forlo!thedaysarehasteningonByGmBFBEglorioussongofold,Fromangelsbendingpeacefulwingsunfurled,Andstilltheirheavenlyworldhathsufferedlong;Beneaththeangelformsarebendinglow,Whotoilalongtheprophetbardsforetold,WhenwiththeeverFEFBneartheearthTotouchtheirharpsofgold;“PeacemusicfloatsO’erallthewearyworld;AstrainhaverolledTwothousandyearsofwrong,AndclimbingwayWithpainfulstepsandslow,LookcirclingyearsComesroundtheageofgold,WhenBDGmBontheearth,goodwilltomen,FromboveitssadandlowlyplainsTheyman,atwarwithman,hearsnotThenow!forgladandgoldenhoursComepeaceshalloveralltheearthItsFEBBEheaven’sallgraciousKing:”Theworldinsolemnbendonhoveringwing,Andevero’eritslovesongwhichtheybring:Ohushthenoise,yeswiftlyonthewing:Orestbesidetheancientsplendorsfling,AndthewholeworldsendFEFBstillnesslayToheartheangelssing.BabelsoundsTheblessèdangelssingmenofstrife,Andheartheangelssing!wearyroad,Andheartheangelssing!backthesongWhichnowtheangelssing
BBE1.Itcameuponthe2.Stillthroughthecloven3.Yetwiththewoesof4.Andye,beneathlife’s5.Forlo!thedaysareFmidnightclear,ThatskiestheycomeWithsinandstrifeThecrushingload,WhosehasteningonByGmBglorioussongofpeacefulwingsunworldhathsufferedformsarebendingprophetbardsforeFBEold,Fromangelsbendingfurled,Andstilltheirheavenlylong;Beneaththeangellow,Whotoilalongthetold,WhenwiththeeverFneartheearthTomusicfloatsO’erstrainhaverolledTwoclimbingwayWithcirclingyearsComesEFtouchtheirharpsofallthewearythousandyearsofpainfulstepsandroundtheageofBgold;“Peaceworld;Awrong,Andslow,Lookgold,WhenBDontheearth,goodboveitssadandman,atwarwithnow!forgladandpeaceshalloverGmBwilltomen,FromlowlyplainsTheyman,hearsnotThegoldenhoursComealltheearthItsFEheaven’sallgraciousbendonhoveringlovesongwhichtheyswiftlyontheancientsplendorsBKing:”Thewing,Andbring:Owing:Ofling,AndBEworldinsolemnevero’eritshushthenoise,yerestbesidethethewholeworldsendFstillnesslayToBabelsoundsThemenofstrife,Andwearyroad,AndbackthesongWhichEFBheartheangelssing.blessèdangelssingheartheangelssing!heartheangelssing!nowtheangelssing
Melody with chords in B♭ major, concert pitch (voice, piano, guitar, flute, violin).

It Came upon the Midnight Clear lyrics with chords

1

B♭It B♭came upon E♭the Fmidnight clear,

That Gmglorious song B♭of Fold,

From B♭angels bendE♭ing Fnear the earth

To E♭touch their harps Fof B♭gold;

“Peace B♭on Dthe earth, good Gmwill to B♭men,

From Fheaven’s allE♭gracious B♭King:”

The B♭world in solE♭emn Fstillness lay

To E♭hear the anFgels B♭sing.

2

B♭Still B♭through the cloE♭ven Fskies they come

With Gmpeaceful wings B♭unFfurled,

And B♭still their heavE♭enly Fmusic floats

O’er E♭all the weaFry B♭world;

AB♭bove Dits sad and Gmlowly B♭plains

They Fbend on E♭hovering B♭wing,

And B♭ever o’er E♭its FBabel sounds

The E♭blessèd anFgels B♭sing

3

B♭Yet B♭with the woes E♭of Fsin and strife

The Gmworld hath sufB♭fered Flong;

BeB♭neath the anE♭gelFstrain have rolled

Two E♭thousand years Fof B♭wrong,

And B♭man, Dat war with Gmman, hears B♭not

The Flove song E♭which they B♭bring:

O B♭hush the noise, E♭ye Fmen of strife,

And E♭hear the anFgels B♭sing!

4

B♭And B♭ye, beneath E♭life’s Fcrushing load,

Whose Gmforms are bendB♭ing Flow,

Who B♭toil along E♭the Fclimbing way

With E♭painful steps Fand B♭slow,

Look B♭now! Dfor glad and Gmgolden B♭hours

Come Fswiftly E♭on the B♭wing:

O B♭rest beside E♭the Fweary road,

And E♭hear the anFgels B♭sing!

5

B♭For B♭lo! the days E♭are Fhastening on

By Gmprophetbards B♭foreFtold,

When B♭with the evE♭erFcircling years

Comes E♭round the age Fof B♭gold,

When B♭peace Dshall over Gmall the B♭earth

Its Fancient E♭splendors B♭fling,

And B♭the whole world E♭send Fback the song

Which E♭now the anFgels B♭sing

Which key? It Came upon the Midnight Clear in all 12 keys

The melody's lowest and highest notes in each key (C4 is middle C). Choose a key to redraw the music and chords.

KeyLowest noteHighest noteTo sing
E4E5Fairly high
F4F5Fairly high
F♯3F♯4Low start
G3G4Low
G♯3G♯4Low
A3A4Low
A♯3A♯4Low
B3B4Low
C4C5Low
C♯4C♯5Easy for most
D4D5Easy for most
D♯4D♯5Easy for most

Parts for B♭, E♭ and F instruments

Each part below plays the melody in B♭ major, transposed so it sounds at concert pitch with voices and piano, and moved by octaves to sit comfortably on the staff.

InstrumentReads inWritten range
B♭ majorD4–D5
C majorE4–E5
G majorB3–B4
F majorA3–A4
B♭ majorD3–D4
B♭ majorD3–D4

About “It Came upon the Midnight Clear”

Edmund Hamilton Sears, a Massachusetts minister, wrote the words in 1849. They say little about the manger and much about the angels’ song of peace to a world “at war with man”. Willis published the tune in 1850, and it has been the usual American setting ever since.

Sears wrote five stanzas. Many hymnals print four, most often leaving out the third, “Yet with the woes of sin and strife”; the 1905 book prints all five, and so do we.

Feel it in two slow beats to the bar. The fifth line, “Peace on the earth, good will to men”, drops to the low D and climbs back through a chromatic step (D, E, F♯, G): keep it smooth and unhurried.

Melody and words as printed in The Methodist Hymnal (1905), no. 110 (page scan). The 1905 book prints only stanza 1 under the notes, followed by a two-bar “A-men” in dotted halves, which we leave out; we place all five stanzas under the one melody. Each strain ends on a held note that the next pick-up note completes, so we write that note in the same bar. Chord symbols are ours. Words and melody are in the public domain.